Toy developer Christy is close to landing a major client for her company - when he invites her to his holiday party, she's sure she has it locked. Until she realizes the holiday party is a Hanukkah party - and she knows nothing about Judaism! Lucky for Christy, her best friend finds her the perfect tutor; middle school teacher Jonathan Silver is Jewish and looking for someone to school him in Christmas traditions in time to impress his new girlfriend's father. As Christy and Jonathan spend time together teaching one another about their holiday traditions, they realize they have a lot more in common than they initially thought.